A Look Back and Forward

Posted on December 31, 2009 by Charlie Goetsch

Here's a quick look back at some of this year's notable developments in the rail safety world:

March: FRA bans railroad supervisors from medical examining rooms: click here

June: OSHA's Whistleblower Office issues $300,000 in punitive damages against Metro North Railroad for violations of the Federal Rail Safety Act FRSA, setting important precedent: click here

October: Judge confirms FRSA punitive damages apply to publicly owned commuter railroads:click here

November: Judge confirms FRSA prohibits railroads from interfering with the medical treatment plan of employees' treating doctors: click here

November: the first trial in the nation of a FRSA complaint is held in New Haven, Connecticut, against Metro North Railroad (stay tuned for the Judge's decision in early 2010)

And looking forward to 2010, here's hoping:

---for more rulings rejecting rail management's bogus argument that the participation of employees in Railway Labor Act disciplinary proceedings somehow constitutes an "election of remedies" that bars them from the whistleblower protections of the FRSA;

---for judicial rulings establishing that under the FRSA, an employee's treating doctor "trumps" over whatever a railroad manager or medical department may think or want to do;

---to increase the beneficial effect of the FRSA's sister law, the NTSSA (which protects subway system employees who raise safety concerns) by encouraging its application on major subway systems such as New York City Transit and the Washington DC Metro.

Meanwhile, here's wishing everyone a safe and productive new year!

Tags: , , , , ,

New Law Protects Subway Workers From Whistleblower Retaliation

Posted on December 1, 2009 by Charlie Goetsch

In response to last summer's fatal Metro subway crash in Washington DC, Congress now is proposing to extend federal rail safety standards to subway and light-rail lines currently "regulated" by understaffed local safety personnel wielding toothless rules. See NY Times Editorial. This would be a great step forward in ensuring the safety of the commuting public. But there is a little known law already on the books that if put to proper use will be a powerful tool to ensure subway safety.

The National Transit Systems Security Act (NTSSA) is a new whistleblower law that protects subway workers who report hazardous safety conditions. The NTSSA prohibits subways from retaliating or discriminating in any way against employees who report unsafe conditions or any fraud and waste of funds. And if the subway does retaliate, the NTSSA's remedies include reinstatement, back pay, compensatory damages, and up to $250,000 in punitive damages.

So one way to ensure the ongoing safety of subway systems is for employees to vigorously exercise and enforce their new rights under the NTSSA. But this has yet to happen. For example, OSHA's Region II Whistleblower Office confirms that the single largest group of subway workers in the nation, the nearly 40,000 members of TWU Local 100 who work for the MTA NYC Transit Authority, have generated a mere handful of NTSSA complaints. Given the size and history of the NYC subway and bus system, this can only mean the rank and file workers are unaware of their new rights under the NTSSA. Those workers are the eyes and ears of safety in the subway. Something must be done to raise their awareness and encourage them to speak out whenever they see a safety hazard.

Tags: , , , ,