Norfolk Southern Railway is learning the hard way that retaliation doesn’t pay. Despite earlier warnings, it has continued its abusive course of conduct toward employees who report injuries. And so today OSHA issued a Press Release confirming record breaking punitive damage awards in three Federal Rail Safety Act cases: $200,000 + $175,000 + $150,000
railroad injury
OSHA Confirms The FRSA Protects All Railroad Workers Who Follow Their Doctor’s Orders Not To Work
The case of my client Chris Bala established that the FRSA protects ALL railroad workers (not just employees with an on-the-job injury) from attendance discipline when they follow the orders of a treating doctor not to work Why? Because safety trumps discipline. No one wants medically impaired railroad employees reporting to work against their doctor’s…
More FRSA Developments
Important developments in the Federal Rail Safety Act just keep coming. Here are a couple.
OSHA has issued another punitive damages award against Metro North Railroad, this time for harassing an injured employee by interfering with his medical treatment and recovery. The Finding in Cortese v. Metro North Railroad is especially notable because it recognizes…
Two Major New Landmarks Dominate FRSA Landscape
Two new landmarks have appeared in the Federal Rail Safety Act landscape, one erected by a federal court jury and the other by OSHA’s top policy makers. Last week’s $1 million punitive damages jury award for my client is indeed historic, but should not overshadow a recent seminal Memo by OSHA of equal importance.
The…
First FRSA Jury Awards $1 Million in Punitive Damages!
Yesterday, at the end of the first Federal Rail Safety Act jury trial in the nation, I asked the federal jury to send a message to every railroad in the country. An unmistakable message that singling out injured workers for discipline while ignoring management’s role will not be tolerated. An unmistakable message that rail management’s…
Dept of Labor Elevates Status of Whistleblower Office
In an encouraging sign to whistleblowers, the Department of Labor has elevated the status of its Office of the Whistleblower Protection Program (OWPP) so it now reports directly to the Head of OSHA, Assistant Secretary Dr. David Michaels. This puts whistleblower protection on an equal footing with OSHA’s health and safety enforcement, and increases the…
Two Decisions Clarifying FRSA Adverse Differential Treatment
The Federal Rail Safety Act prohibits a railroad from “discriminating in any way” against an employee who engages in the protected activity of raising a safety concern or reporting an injury. Such discrimination can take many forms, but two recent decisions highlight a classic example: namely, treating a worker differently from other similarly situated workers.…
How Not To Settle FRSA Claims
No matter what a railroad may try to tell you, a Federal Rail Safety Act claim under OSHA jurisdiction cannot be settled without the express written approval of OSHA. Here’s why.
The FRSA itself states: “The rights and remedies in this section may not be waived by any agreement . . .” 49 USC 20109(h).
The Escalating Cost of FRSA Violations
The damages for violations of the Federal Rail Safety Act just keep expanding. The latest record breaker goes against the Union Pacific Railroad: $175,000 in punitive damages and $100,000 for emotional distress, all for firing a conductor who reported a minor injury.
In addition to the immediate reinstatement, lost wages, and attorney fees ordered,…
FRSA Bars Any Attorney Fee Awards To Railroads
If a railroad worker wins his Federal Rail Safety Act complaint, the railroad has to pay all his attorney fees. But if a FRSA complaint fails, the railroad cannot recover any attorney fees or costs against the worker.
Administrative Law Judge Adele H. Odegard’s decision in Vason v. Port Authority Trans Hudson (PATH) explains why:…