Metro North Railroad’s attempt to exempt itself from punitive damages under the Federal Rail Safety Act has failed. In a case of first impression, an ALJ has just ruled that ALL railroads–including publicly owned commuter railroads–are subject to the FRSA’s punitive damage remedy. Plus, the ALJ is requiring Metro North Railroad to go through the
Why Railroad Managers Retaliate
Here’s an open secret: retaliation is the hallmark of an insecure manager who has no clue how to lead workers and who knows in his heart he is not qualified to be in a position of power.
Insecure rail managers perceive reports of safety concerns or injuries as a personal affront to their authority and…
Judge Rules FRSA Complaints Not Precluded By RLA Proceedings
The railroads obviously have gotten together and agreed to push the bogus argument that any involvement by an employee in the Railway Labor Act CBA grievance-discipline process automatically constitutes an "election of remedies" under Federal Rail Safety Act subsection (f) that precludes any FRSA complaint. It is a bogus argument because it completely ignores the effect…
Subcontracting Is No Escape From FELA and FRSA Liability
Rail union rep Joe Coleman from Seattle has a question about the FELA liability of railroads who contract out work. His General Foreman recently hired subcontractors to band freight car loads that had shifted due to broken banding, and when challenged tried to justify it by arguing that since the subcontractors are self-insured, the railroad…
OSHA HAMMERS METRO NORTH WITH $300,000 IN FRSA PUNITIVE DAMAGES!
Talk about sending a message! OSHA has blown the whistle on Metro North Railroad’s culture of retaliation. Big time. No longer do railroad workers have to fear reporting an injury or a safety violation. The days when railroad managers could retaliate with impunity are officially over. Every railroad in the country is now on notice…
FRA Bars Supervisors From Medical Exam Rooms
The opportunities for railroad supervisors to harass injured workers just keeps getting smaller and smaller. The Federal Railroad Administration has now put a stop to the practice of railroad supervisors accompanying injured employees into medical exam rooms. The FRA issued a Notice of Interpretation declaring it to be a violation of federal regulations for a …
OSHA Orders $7.9 Million In Whistleblower Damages
Need more proof that retaliation doesn’t pay? Check out this scenario. Workers raise safety concerns with their carrier and OSHA. Carrier files a defamation lawsuit against the workers. Workers file Whistleblower complaint with OSHA. OSHA investigation finds lawsuit was in retaliation for the workers’ protected activity, and PRESTO! the carrier has to pay $7.8…
Railroads Beware! Refusal to Cooperate Risks Devastating Adverse Inference
Q: What is the quickest way for a railroad to end up with a punitive damages Order against it?
A: Refuse to cooperate with an OSHA Federal Railroad Safety Act investigation.
Some railroads have decided to play cute with OSHA by refusing to produce documents on the ground that the FRSA does not give OSHA…
NJ Transit Learns the High Cost of Retaliation
Here’s stark confirmation that the cost of retaliation is punitive damages and broken management careers.
A jury in Newark, New Jersey, just found that the top manager in the NJ Transit Police Department, Chief Joseph Bober, retaliated against female officer Theresa Frizalone after she complained about discrimination. The jury awarded her $1.5 million in…
FRSA’s Sharp Teeth Starting To Bite Railroads
Talk about leveling the playing field. OSHA’s FRSA Whistleblowers have sent another powerful message to rail management: sorry guys, but the days of business as usual are officially over. Supervisors are no longer free to retaliate at will against employees who raise safety concerns.
It all started when a Union Pacific Railroad Company welder performing…